Monday, July 20, 2015

Book Reviews: What's Helpful, What's Not

by Susanne Dietze

Ah, book reviews. Love 'em and hate 'em at the same time? You're not alone.

This has been a big topic of conversation lately among some of my friends, women who are readers and women who are readers/authors.

Among the things I've heard from readers (and perhaps even thought to myself while I'm perusing book reviews for potential reads on Amazon):

"I really want to know what people think of a book, but some of these reviews sound like they were written by the author's friends. That means their reviews aren't honest."

"Why did this reader give it a 2-star rating and then say they liked it?"

Or, from an author's perspective:

"Someone gave my book a 1-star rating based on the packaging, not the story!"

"Someone gave my book a 1-star rating! It's fine they didn't like it, but why did they have to be so mean about it?"

Earlier, I posted on my blog on ways to help an author. Writing book reviews is one of the things I mentioned specifically as something that can help authors gain new readers--by letting readers know if the book is of a genre they like or worth their time, especially considering the price of purchase.

Reviews are also sometimes viewed by others in the industry, like editors. I'm not saying editors read every review (they're busy people) but some editors pay attention to authors' social media stats and reviews, along with sales and awards.

I'm not saying reviews make or break an author's career. But they can prove influential to prospective readers, and they often let authors know what's working in their writing...and what's not.

(Full disclosure: I only have one book out, and it's an anthology. Others are waaay more qualified to speak on this point, but here goes anyway.)

So what's helpful (according to the people I talked with) when writing a book review?
  • Know that readers, authors, and editors appreciate the time you're taking to write a review. Your gift of service is a blessing!
  • Some sites, like Amazon, require a review to accompany a rating, but others, like Goodreads, don't. Try to write a few words to explain your rating, anyway. I recently contemplated purchasing a sequel to a book I enjoyed. The reviews let me know that several readers finished the book feeling frustrated about their perceived regression in the characters' developments. That told me so much more than a 3-star review without an explanation.
  • State the facts about the story and why you enjoyed it/didn't enjoy it. Was the story engaging? Was there a specific reason you didn't like it? Is the issue you have with a book a major stumbling block... or personal preference? I've liked a few movies that critics graded an F, and disliked a few well-regarded movies, but I'd read reviews in advance and determined the critic and I judged on different merits. Same with books. One reviewer's three-star rating might be my perfect cozy afternoon read. Saying something's just not your cup of tea is perfectly ok.
  • Consider the book's audience. It's not fair to criticize a book for being what it's supposed to be, ie, by disparaging the spiritual elements in a Christian book, finding the hero too young when the book is a YA, or for bemoaning the lack of blood and gore in a cozy mystery.
  • Mention if you received the book in exchange for an honest, unbiased review. This is the law.
What's not helpful when writing a book review?
  • It's not an unhelpful thing, but don't stress about recapping the book. Some reviews summarize the plot or back-cover copy, which can be helpful to readers, but it isn't necessary.
  • Don't rate the packaging, shipping speed, book cover, or other things an author has no control over. Sometimes this extends to the title, too.
  • Refrain from spilling the author's private info. You may be the author's Facebook friend. Or their relative. You may know where she went to high school or where she gets her hair cut. This information, spread on the world wide web, is an invasion of her privacy, and to many readers, it negates anything positive that was mentioned in the review because it makes a review sound inauthentic or biased.
  • Just like sharing personal info about the author makes it sound as if a positive review is done by a positively-biased crony, cruelty or foul words can make a negative review sound equally biased, but to the other extreme. Harsh language isn't polite.
  • Avoid spoiling the plot. Announce if you're divulging anything twisty or pertaining to the end with an all-caps SPOILER ALERT.
Some other facts about book reviews?
  • Yes, authors do review their friends' work sometimes. Authors are big readers, too.
  • Mean-spirited reviews do hurt authors' feelings sometimes. Other times, not so much. But I think it's fair to say authors don't expect everyone to love their books, but nobody likes to be called names.
  • Book reviews last forever. Or until the internet explodes. Just as in real life, our words stick around.
What do you think when you read book reviews? Do you often review products you buy?

Susanne Dietze writes historical romance. You can find her on her website,


  1. I try to keep things simple with my book reviews. What I liked (or didn't like and why). Most of the time, I've loved the books and I do tend to put in a disclaimer if I really like an author so people know why I liked the book so much. (or if I won the book) I think I've done one or two books where I didn't really like the book, but also mentioned why and that I realized other people might like the book even though I didn't.
    Really snarky reviews catch my attention and I sometimes look at that person's other reviews to see if they are just snarky people in general. Usually they are. so I ignore them (or shoot up a prayer for them because they appear to be really unhappy and are just wanting some company in their misery)

    this reminds me that I'm behind on posting reviews for authors I like. not good. I want to be helpful, since the authors have been so good to me. (including ladies from here, btw - you ladies do great posts)

  2. Hey DebH! I really like your attitude of blessing: sharing honestly but fairly, with kindness. Sometimes I look at snarky reviews, too, to see if it's a habit with a reviewer.

    Thanks for your reviews, and for coming by today! Blessings!

  3. I used to always recap the characters, setting and outline to ground the reader into the story. One reason is that I've seen so many reviews that say it's a good book, but if I have to interview the author and I haven't read it, saying it's a good book doesn't give me any insight into the book inself. Some authors don't keep their websites up, the back cover blurbs are sketchy, and the bookcovers are so generic, the setting could be anytime.

    But then I read that readers can automatically tell if the reviewer is a writer or a reader and if it's a writer, they automatically discount that reviewer because they assume it's a friend of the author. She went on to list the differences.

    That changed my attitude somewhat. I still feel it's important to present the basic facts, but I won't be recapping like I have in the past. Does that make sense?

    1. It makes total sense, Anita Mae. I think you're right to include the book's setting in the review, especially if the cover doesn't make it obvious.

      I bought a book once b/c the model on the cover wore a Regency-style gown and the back cover sounded like a Regency--but didn't state it explicitly. English country manor, blah blah. But it turned out to be a Victorian. Not a big thing but I felt like I was in a restaurant and ordered one thing and got another.

  4. I think sometimes reader reviewers are confused by the rating system. They think one-star is the very best. It's an understandable mistake, but it can drag down a book's rating pretty quickly.

    All in all, I appreciate reviews, even the negative ones. I often learn from them . . . even if all I learn is that I can't please everyone. ;)

    1. Learning we can't please everyone (and shouldn't try) is one of life's most valuable lessons...and one of the most difficult things in the world to me. Sigh.

  5. Such good information, Susie! Thank you for putting this together.


Share This Post

How Our Giveaways Work: The Official Rules

We, the ladies of Inkwell Inspirations, would love to give free stuff to everybody. Since we can't, we will often have a giveaway in conjunction with a specific post. Unless otherwise stated, one winner will be drawn from comments left on that post between the date it was published and the end of the giveaway as determined in the post. Entries must be accompanied by a valid email address. This address is used only to contact the commenter in the event that he/she is the winner, and will not be sold, distributed, or used in any other fashion. The odds of winning depend on the number of entrants. NO PURCHASE, PLEDGE, OR DONATION NECESSARY TO ENTER OR TO WIN. ALL FEDERAL, STATE, LOCAL AND MUNICIPAL LAWS AND REGULATIONS APPLY. VOID WHERE PROHIBITED.