(The Secret Society of Spinsters Book #1): A Christian Opposites Attract Frontier Western Historical Romance with Cowboys
REBECCA'S REVIEW:
"That man and his obnoxious charm. Good grief. She'd almost shared a smile with him."
Self declared independent woman, active member of the Women's Christian Temperance Union, and recent recruit to the Secret Society of Spinsters, Noreen O'Sullivan doesn't have time to be making eyes at the handsome deputy sheriff of Albany, Texas, who has just bodily removed her (very politely, of course) from her temperance campaign in front of the local saloon. If she was being honest with herself, it had probably been a good idea, since the proprietor of the Salt Fork Saloon was getting a bit, shall we say, "salty"?
Deputy James Paxton takes his job as keeper of the peace very seriously, but the sassy Miss O'Sullivan is as pretty as a picture and stubborn as a mule. If he can just convince her to go about her public campaigning a little differently, oh, who he is kidding?
When James is forced to make a tricky decision, he and the purpose driven Miss O'Sullivan end up spending some unexpected time together, forcing them both to rethink priorities. Will it be enough?
What did I love most about this book? Virtually everything. The clever setting, the sparks of instantaneous attraction, the extraordinary word flow (I read all but 50 pages in one sitting) the deep spiritual truths, and of course the wit! . . . always the wit!
A perfectly delightful and engaging western romance!
*I voluntarily reviewed a copy of this book from the publisher, the opinions stated above are entirely my own.
WINNIE'S REVIEW:
“She’d grown lax of late. Hadn’t protested in nearly three weeks.”
“He couldn’t afford to let her out-stubborn him.”
With a setting in Texas in 1894, a heroine who is bound and determined to defend the cause of prohibition, and a deputy who is hoping to be elected sheriff and wants to keep the peace, what could possibly go wrong?
I’m always delighted to read another Karen Witemeyer story, and Taming Lady Temperance lived up to my anticipation. This first book in The Secret Society of Spinsters is full of well-drawn, multi-layered, and realistically flawed characters, and the story line caught my attention quickly.
The main characters, Noreen O’Sullivan and Deputy James Paxton, are engaging and entertaining. Noreen is independent, headstrong, and spunky. Dependable and upstanding James is just the person to keep her in check. I thoroughly enjoyed the banter between them and the signature wit and humor Witemeyer injects into her stories. I found myself chuckling and laughing out loud at some of the pictures that were evoked.
“. . . this woman was on a mission. A mission that apparently involved him. He swallowed and steeled himself for what was to come. The tenacity he’d just admitted to admiring was about to bury its teeth into his leg, and he wasn’t at all certain he’d be able to shake free.”
“That man and his obnoxious charm. Good grief. She’d almost shared a smile with him. Thankfully, she’d stopped herself in time.”
It was satisfying to see the relationship between Noreen and James change as they interacted and began to get to know each other better. I loved the way they were able to work together and solve problems, even as they were exasperating each other.
“He might not have to worry about Noreen O'Sullivan ruining his chances to be elected sheriff, after all. Apparently, he was perfectly capable of blackening public opinion of his fitness for office all on his lonesome.”
“Her hackles had been raised, and he was bound to get jabbed by a few of them before this was over.”
With plenty of action, intrigue, inspiration, and romance, this book kept me turning the pages. The stellar cast of secondary characters added much to the tale, and I’m hoping that some of the Spinster Society sisters will get their own stories soon.
*I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy from Bethany House. All opinions are my own.
PAULA'S REVIEW:
Karen Witemeyer is back at it again. This time with a determined heroine Noreen, The Temperance Terror! In Albany, Texas when women were marching against the evils of alcohol, Noreen takes up the cause. Based on her background, she has seen the results from overindulgence.
Filled with humor and witty banter and a heroine who puts everything on the line for what she believes in, there is also Deputy James Paxton who must uphold the law even when the girl who catches his eye tends to break it!
“I won’t be placated, Deputy Paxton. And I won’t succumb to your charms, so aim that smile of yours elsewhere.” “But James found her fascinating as well. Hard not to with all that passion zinging around beneath her surface.”
James has his work cut out for him when he encounters the feisty Noreen, while at the same time trying to appease the other inhabitants of the town. James is the perfect foil for Noreen as he dispenses godly wisdom with his steady demeanor.
Join the ladies of The Secret Society of Spinsters as they try to reform their little town in 1894. A totally enjoyable read with faith lessons, some excitement and a sweet romance.
*A complimentary copy of this book was provided by Bethany House. I was not required to post a favorable review. All opinions are mine alone.* 5 stars and a solid faith thread
BackCover Blurb:
When passion for justice conflicts with the heart, which will prevail?
Noreen O'Sullivan is an enthusiastic member of the Woman's Christian Temperance Union and believes herself called to defend the cause of prohibition. When she's invited to join the Secret Society of Spinsters, Noreen jumps at the chance to rally others to her movement and shut down the local saloon for good. However, her passionate campaigning often puts her at odds with the men around her--including the local deputy.
Deputy James Paxton believes in preserving the peace, but Miss O'Sullivan has been disturbing his peace for months. If James wants to be elected sheriff, he can't afford to be seen as her ally. But when Noreen ropes him into helping her plan a temperance march, their growing closeness sparks unexpected feelings. Then tensions escalate at the saloon and accusations fly. James must choose between upholding his badge and protecting the woman who's captured his heart--knowing either choice could cost him everything.
Karen Witemeyer presents a swoony Western romance with a determined heroine, cowboys, prohibition, and the rivals-to-lovers and duty vs. desire tropes. Fans of Mary Connealy and frontier romances set in the Old West will savor this clean, historical read.
Bethany House Publishing, February, 2026
Available in digital ebook, paperback, hardcover, and audiobook:
Buy TAMING LADY TEMPERANCE at Amazon, Christianbook, or Baker Book House