An Edwardian Dual-Timeline Historical Mystery set on the Cornish Coast (The House on the Edge of the Cliff Book 1)
WINNIE'S REVIEW:
“Some stories are lost to time. Some are rewritten. And some—broken, imperfect, and true—continue to echo, even in minds that have forgotten the details.”
I never miss a chance to read a new Joanna Davidson Politano book. Her stories are always extremely creative with multi-layered, complex characters and brilliantly composed plots. The twists and turns always keep me guessing and turning pages to the end.
The Life She Forgot is a perfect example of Politano’s writing genius. In 1913 Cornwall, Merryn has forgotten everything about her former life. When she impulsively marries AJ Winthrop, a man she has only known a very short time, they travel the Cornish shore trying to resurrect her memories. As she begins to remember another man, their relationship is threatened.
Another timeline in the story features William in 1947, broken by the war and estranged from his wife, as he tries to solve the mystery of a portrait of a beautiful woman. I was amazed at the way the author wove these two timelines together to complete this exquisite and captivating tale.
“Love is. . . two broken people who find one another and somehow embrace the broken pieces.”
Filled with mystery, intrigue, and threads of forgiveness, love, faith, and hope, this story kept me entertained and guessing through all the plot twists. I’m anxiously waiting to see what tale Politano has dreamed up next.
*I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy. All opinions are my own.
PAULA'S REVIEW:
In 1913 Merryn has lost her memory but not her tenacity. She is slowly regaining snippets of events but they haunt her because they promise something that is just out of her reach.
This is a superb, emotional journey as Merryn searches the coast of Cornwall with her new husband Ansel. But is he her only husband? Her memories hint at another wedding. A.J. (Ansel) is a complex character who seems clearly in love with his wife. So much mystery and a present threat when Merryn is given custody of Cecil and his inheritance when Lady St. Laurent dies. Her daughter has other ideas.
I highlighted so many relevant, haunting passages: “We think of memories as a log book, but they are more than that. They give us a framework through which to view our present.”
In the 1947 era of this dual time story, William Thatcher has returned from war a broken man who feels unworthy. A painting he finds puts him on a quest to find the artist and subject of the artwork. This connects the two timelines in a unique way,
It was enchanting to discover the connections between the characters and mesmerizing to read about their journeys.
There were several great allusions to Biblical passages, the foremost being:
“Love is invaluable because of what it has cost someone.”
“Never build your house on sand when rock is available to you. Never build it on anything that can move. Because eventually, it will.”
This author never ceases to amaze me with her heartfelt voice, beautiful words and meaningful messages.
*A complimentary copy of this book was provided by the author. I was not required to post a favorable review. All opinions are mine alone.*Beyond 5 stars and a solid faith thread
BackCover Blurb:
He promised to help her reclaim the memories she lost—no matter what they found.
Until she remembered another man.
Cornwall, 1913
For three years, Merryn has lived without a past—no family, no history, no home that's truly hers.
When the threat of being locked away for her own “protection” looms, she takes a desperate chance on AJ Winthrop—a warmhearted, whimsical stranger who offers a hasty marriage of convenience and a promise: he will take her back to Cornwall and help her uncover the truth about who she once was.
But along the wild Cornish coast, the memories that begin to surface are not the ones she expects.
Another man.
Another wedding.
A life that may already be hers.
When a hidden painting reveals Merryn’s own face staring back from another life, the fragile life she’s begun to build with AJ begins to unravel. Because the truth waiting in her past could destroy the love she’s only just found.
Cornwall, 1947
Haunted by the war and estranged from the wife he still loves, William Crawford is determined to save their family home for her—even if it means selling the mysterious portrait of Merryn Dunn tucked away in his cottage. But the secrets hidden within the painting threaten to overturn everything he believes…or lead him toward a redemption he never expected.
Decades apart, two lives are bound by a single portrait—and the truth it refuses to keep hidden. This sweeping dual-timeline historical mystery weaves together lost memories, buried truths, and a love story that refuses to fade.
Perfect for fans of Mimi Matthews, Susanna Kearsley, and Kate Morton.
Grafted Page Press, April, 2026
Available in digital ebook, paperback, and audiobook: